The independent voice of cricket

Sheffield Shield 2023/24

Watch: ‘Has the captain called him back?’ – Jake Fraser-McGurk allowed to continue batting after being given out in Sheffield Shield clash

Victoria allowed Jake Fraser-McGurk to continue batting despite given out by the umpire in the Sheffield Shield 2023/24 game.
by Wisden Staff 2 minute read

Watch: ‘Has the captain called him back?’ – Jake Fraser-McGurk was allowed to continue batting after being given out in the Sheffield Shield match between Victoria and South Australia at the Adelaide Oval.

A month after blasting the fastest ever List A century off just 29 balls, Fraser-McGurk smashed another blazing ton for South Australia but this time in the Sheffield Shield. In reply to Victoria’s 278, he hit 12 boundaries during his 106-ball 101 to rescue South Australia from 16-4 to 252-all-out.

However, the innings started on a controversial note when he was given out on 19, caught at slip by Peter Handscomb while attempting a cover drive against left-arm spinner Doug Warren. Although the Victorians rejoiced at the umpire’s decision, Fraser-McGurk didn’t leave the crease before being allowed to continue with his batting by the opposition.


Fraser-McGurk explained what happened after play. He said: “I missed it by probably three feet, it spun a fair bit and I think it came off Sam Harper’s glove before Peter Handscomb caught it. Sometimes they (opposition teams) are just like ‘yay’ … and it could have been not a serious appeal, but then the umpire’s starting to nod his head and I was a bit in disbelief.

“So I started walking off, then seconds later he (umpire Michael Graham-Smith) changes his decision and the Vic boys weren’t too happy with that because they think they had a few unlucky decisions.

“But that’s the game, and in the end it was the right umpiring call and that’s what you want.”

The reprieve allowed the high rated Fraser-McGurk to eventually compile his first hundred in first-class cricket.

Watch Jake Fraser-McGurk get a reprieve | Sheffield Shield 2023/24

Subscribe to the Wisden Cricket YouTube channel for post-match analysis, player interviews, and much more.

Have Your Say

Become a Wisden member

  • Exclusive offers and competitions
  • Money-can’t-buy experiences
  • Join the Wisden community
  • Sign up for free
Latest magazine

Get the magazine

12 Issues for just £39.99