The independent voice of cricket

Australia v India

‘Paine ful review’ – Fans unimpressed after another failed DRS call

Paine DRS
by Wisden Staff 2 minute read

Tim Paine’s use of the DRS system came into focus once again in the ongoing Australia-India Test series, with the hosts losing their first review of the Brisbane Test early on the third day.

The incident took place in the 49th over of the India innings, just two overs after Mayank Agarwal had replaced Cheteshwar Pujara at the crease. It was Mayank’s first stint in the middle order, returning to the XI after being dropped for Rohit Sharma in the third Test.

Having rewarded for a morning of perseverance through Pujara’s dismissal, Australia looked to capitalise on their position by closing in on the new batsman. They sniffed an opportunity on the fifth ball of the 49th over, off a down-the-leg delivery from Pat Cummins.

Agarwal tried to shift across and flick it to square leg. The ball made a noise as it crossed the batsman, thus enthusing the Australia players, especially their skipper.

As soon as the appeal was made, Shane Warne, who was on air at that point, immediately said that he felt the ball would have hit the thigh pad. The former Australia cricketer pointed out that the thudding noise was specific to the thigh pad more than the glove. Additionally, there seemed to be a gap between the bat and ball, and Cummins appeared a tad uncertain as well. However, the Australia skipper decided to go for the review.

The big screen confirmed Warne’s assessment though, as there was daylight between the bat and ball, and the noise had come off the thigh pad.

Here’s how the internet reacted to the review:





Have Your Say

Become a Wisden member

  • Exclusive offers and competitions
  • Money-can’t-buy experiences
  • Join the Wisden community
  • Sign up for free
Latest magazine

Get the magazine

12 Issues for just £39.99